Photo: Alamy
A Utah judge ruled Monday that a transcript and audio recording from a closed-door hearing connected to the killing of conservative activist Charlie Kirk can be released, though with certain redactions.
Judge Tony Graf said the transcript from the October proceeding would be made public immediately, while the audio would be released in the coming weeks once redactions are complete. The hearing concerned whether the defendant, 22-year-old Tyler Robinson, could appear in court unshackled and in plain clothes.
Robinson has been charged with aggravated murder, two counts of obstruction of justice, witness tampering and committing a violent offense in the presence of a child.
Graf ruled that Robinson could wear civilian clothing but must remain restrained during court appearances. The judge said the transcript would omit security information but would not exclude details already publicly known, according to The Hill.
“If this information poses a risk of violating defendant’s right to a fair trial, defendant’s first line of defense is found in the rules of evidence in criminal procedure,” Graf wrote.
The judge also denied a motion by media organizations seeking limited-party status in the case but directed both prosecutors and defense attorneys to notify the press of upcoming hearings and case developments.
“This is not a jail. This is your honor’s courtroom,” Graf said, adding that “what security measures are necessary to ensure everybody’s safety, including Mr. Robinson’s, are your honor’s decisions, not the sheriff’s decisions.”
Graf also argued against increased security due to public attention concerning the case.
” I’ve received some wacky phone calls and e-mails, people telling me what they think happened here. It’s noise,” Graf said.
Robinson’s next court appearance is scheduled for Jan. 16, 2026.
In a separate decision Monday, Judge Graf rejected a motion from media attorneys seeking to formally intervene in the case. He said journalists do not need to be designated parties to obtain access to court documents.
Prosecutors are expected to present their evidence against Robinson during a preliminary hearing set for May 18.
